"You get what you pay for."
I was reminded of this statement when I opened my pochade box one day in search of my little painting knife. I had just purchased the inexpensive (ie. cheap), small-bladed, trowel-shaped painting knife, and "lovingly placed it inside" my painting box. It was only the second time I had brought it into the field with me. You would expect that it could withstand being jostled around while walking a few hundred yards into the woods, or, as in my case, stand up to some bumps while I packed quickly under the watchful eyes of an armed and badged art-lover. When I opened my pochade, I was disappointed by what I saw.
My nearly-new painting knife looked like someone had put it through a tube-wringer. Actually, it looked as if someone had used it to prize masticated gum from under movie theater seats, then used it to gap spark plugs, AND THEN put it in a tube-wringer. It was, at best, a palette knife now, or could be used for some funky looking branches, but if I wanted to use it for hard, straight edges, I was out of luck. Perhaps I could use it to defend myself against squirrels, in a pinch, but that was not what I had originally intended for its use.
I have nearly two dozen painting knives and palette knives. I'm not sure why. There was a sale, I think, and there was a large set for a good price, and I convinced myself I was going to use them for painting. Instead, I picked my favorite shapes, and used them for paint-mixing only. Some broke over time, and I tried to fix them with epoxy or glue. Some broke the first day out of the gates and were unceremoniously tossed in a flurry of rude gesticulations and loud, inventive swearing. Others found new lives in my DIY home repairs, filling nail holes, or adding mastic to some mighty small bathroom tiles I had to adhere to a wall, one at a time, after firing an incompetent contractor (in a flurry of rude gesticulations and loud, inventive swearing).
Then one day, I felt a burning in my backside. I happened to be in an art supply store at the time. It turned out, I had my wallet in my rear pocket, and in that wallet was a little bit of money, which was causing me pain. I've noticed that this combination of art supplies and cash tend to cause this problem for me, and the only cure is to discard the money as fast as possible. So I bought another painting knife, but what a painting knife it was!

What did my $31.80 (with coupon and a membership discount card) get me? A
HK Holbein, hand-forged, stainless steel, Series SX, No. 2 painting knife! These knives are made in Seki City, Japan, a region settled by master sword makers 800 years ago, who chose the area because its natural resources were so beneficial to metal working. It is forged from a single piece of metal, and the blade is of a uniform 0.1 mm thickness which enables a delicate flexibility, yet with a fine tempering for nice bounce back to its correct shape. The neck has a 12 degree bend which keeps your knuckles out of the paint and off the canvas, and the overall weight and balance are excellent. As you use them, the blade thickness wears down, making it more flexible and sharper (for use against squirrels and contractors). I was so happy with the knife, I bought another Series SX just a few days later. I have never had an issue with either of them.


Therefore, I would recommend these knives to everyone, except for one small problem: they've been discontinued. You can still find them in some art stores, but the prices have not been marked down, and you'll have to settle for whatever is left in inventory by this time. Holbein makes other knives, which may be just as good. There is a
Series MX which I came across that are, I think, the same quality knives in a matte finish, though there are fewer shapes from which to choose . The Series 1066 steel, and the 1066S stainless steel also look good, though perhaps a little less substantial. The Ecolse line of painting knives are the student grade, and although they are not hand-forged, they are still made in Seki City.
These may cost more than your average painting knife, but if you need a new knife, and want an exceptional quality art tool that will last for decades, keep your eyes open for the Series SX while there are still a few left out there (in other words, before I find them).